Healthcare for London: Questions & Answers
London’s population is growing and living longer. London is facing a number of health challenges including huge health inequalities. We need to: |
||
|
||
|
||
The proposals agreed by the JCPCT will improve the health of Londoners by: |
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
The proposals were developed by clinicians and are supported by the public and organisations. They will improve quality and access of healthcare in London. |
||
| What are the changes? | ||
| The JCPCT have agreed to: | ||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
| What about polyclinics? | ||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Look at the statistics |
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Questions and answers |
||
The BMA, LMC, GP Newspaper and Pulse are all actively campaigning against polyclinics. How can you proceed with these plans in the face of such opposition? |
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
| What is a polyclinic? | ||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
You claim that polyclinics can offer a wider range of services, give some examples |
||
A polyclinic could offer: |
||
|
||
Why are you introducing polyclinics? |
||
|
||
| Is this a top-down, one-size-all ‘solution’? | ||
There is no single solution. The polyclinic model is flexible so that it can be developed with local GPs, other primary care professionals and local communities to create health and wellbeing services that meet their needs and reduce health inequalities. |
||
| Would polyclinics need to be a certain size? | ||
No. Current planning is for polyclinics to serve populations of around 50,000 and to support a core range of services. However, PCTs can work with local clinicians and the local community to develop polyclinics to the size and shape they need to offer the services that local people need. Our ideas of what a polyclinic looks like will continue to change and grow as they are implemented. |
||
| Does this mean that Londoners will no longer be able to see their own GP? | ||
No. The relationship between the patients and his or her GP is extremely important. Patients will see their own GP as they do now for routine appointments. However, if your GP then identified that you needed a blood test, for example, that he or she could not provide, then you could go to another GP or clinic nearby for this, rather than having to go to hospital. |
||
| It sounds as though polyclinics are going to be imposed on Londoners? | ||
No. There is no intention to ‘impose’ Polyclinics on London’s communities. Patients can choose their GP. NHS London does believe that there is a need for change and our expectation is that PCTs will look at the polyclinic model. However, it is up to PCTs and the public to decide the exact detail. This is about offering people a wider range of services. |
||
How do you think GPs will feel about being told how to run their primary care practice by a surgeon? |
||
The proposals in Healthcare for London were developed by clinicians including GPs. There were six clinical working groups which helped shape A Framework for Action as well as a multitude of meetings and events. Additionally, more than 5,000 individuals and groups responded to Healthcare for London: Consulting the Capital. |
||
| Aren’t GPs just being over-protective? | ||
They are being protective – and that is understandable as they care about their patients and want to ensure that we move forward carefully to build on the good things that many GPs have achieved. |
||
Will GPs be ‘herded’ or forced against their will? |
||
No. GPs will not be forced into polyclinics against their will. This would not be possible under existing GP contracts. GPs would be free to choose whether they joined a polyclinic or not. Their practice list would remain theirs wherever they chose to work from. |
||
| Do GPs’ surgeries really need to open for longer hours? | ||
80% of Londoners said they wanted GP surgeries to be open for appointments in the evenings and at weekends. This may be one of the reasons why so many people attend A & E at these times when GP care might be more appropriate. |
||
| What about the extra burden on GPs? | ||
We don’t believe there has to be extra burden on GPs. For instance, in the networked model GPs could work together to offer an extended hours service with each GP working perhaps one evening a month, instead of a day. |
||
Will this mean less independence for GPs? Will they lose their premises, for example? |
||
This is a big worry for many GPs but we believe that there are opportunities here for GPs to shape the way this develops. GPs may want to form consortia to bid for services, for example. The polyclinic model does not mean GPs lose their independence and become salaried doctors. The model allows for partnerships buying or leasing premises for a same-site model or using their own premises in a network of practices. |
||
Won’t polyclinics increase travel times? |
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
We will continue working with Transport for London to ensure that we understand the implications on travel times of any decisions. Work will also be done locally between PCTs and local authorities when local services are being planned. |
||
The polyclinic model means that patients will spend less time travelling to hospitals. Ensuring access and minimising travel times will be important when planning polyclinics. |
||
| What support/evidence is there for the model? | ||
|
||
|
||
|
||
| Does this mean privatisation? | ||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Won’t this mean that local services such as community pharmacies might have to close? |
||
Healthcare for London is working closely with professional groups including community pharmacists. Pharmacy would be a core service provided as part of a polyclinic model. However, most Londoners would continue to use their local pharmacy for medication and self-care including repeat prescriptions; about 80% of prescriptions are repeats. |
||
Community pharmacists already perform a very useful service in the community and this role is expanding meaning more people will visit their pharmacist for advice and treatment in the future, such as help with managing diabetes or stopping smoking. |
||
What is the benefit of shutting down hundreds of GP surgeries in areas where primary care is being delivered to a good standard? |
||
We are not advocating shutting down hundreds of GP surgeries where primary care is being delivered to a good standard. GP surgeries that are providing excellent services to all members of their communities will simply continue to do so. |
||
| Are polyclinics really more cost effective than GP practices? | ||
Polyclinics do not replace GP practices. There are various sources of savings e.g.: |
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Have you done any modelling about the scale of potential savings of moving care from hospitals into the community? |
||
We believe a number of services can be provided to the same quality possibly more cheaply in the community. We are working on modelling tools for PCTs to look at the impact of this. |
||
| However, the aim is to improve patient care not to provide savings. | ||
| What about plans to pilot the polyclinic approach? | ||
We will be evaluating polyclinics as they develop. All 31 PCTs in London are looking at the polyclinic service model through a three-month developmental programme. |
||
| Are there currently any polyclinics in London? | ||
There are none in London currently. However, there are examples of GP practices already offering an expanded service in London. |
||
There are a lot of single-handed GP practices, out in the East End in particular. It is said that a polyclinic could have about 25 GPs practicing in it. If you can hardly get enough GPs in the East End, where are you going to get them from and will they happily move in together? |
||
One of problems is a lack of good buildings so the single site model could help attract GPs to the East End. |
||
Remember too that the polyclinic service model is not restricted to a same-site option. A number of GP practices linked together to provide a range of services could operate as a networked (federated) polyclinic service. So you could have a network operating (and supporting each other) over a wide area. |
||
You seem to be saying the preferred model is the federated polyclinic. Are you now backtracking and saying that the single site model is not a good option after all? |
||
We are listening to clinicians and the public and looking at both options. PCTs and the public will need to decide which model works best for their particular community. |
||
The King’s Fund report says that the evidence is not there to support polyclinics; that people will have to travel further and that London does not have the workforce needed. |
||
The King’s Fund report was produced in response to the single site model. There is no evidence that polyclinics won’t work – the truth is that they are a new idea. The report was very helpful in pointing out some of the considerations we need to take on board in developing the model further. |
||
How many polyclinics does London need and what will be the cost of running them? |
||
We don’t know this yet. If the JCPCT decides that the polyclinic model should be implemented in London, PCTs will need to determine what is right for their community based on local needs. We’re developing financial modelling tools which will help PCTs evaluate the likely costs. |
||
Are PCTs planning services similar to a polyclinic model, pre-empting the outcome of consultation? |
||
Some PCTs have been developing plans over recent years to improve health and wellbeing services in their communities. Some may already include plans to deliver services similar to the polyclinic service model. Healthcare for London would not want to stop this work; in fact, we will encourage PCTs to look at the lessons learnt and information gathered during Healthcare for London: Consulting the Capital, to see if it will help them develop these plans further. |
||
Won’t local hospitals close if you move services to polyclinics and out of local hospitals? |
||
Healthcare for London is not proposing any closures of local hospitals. We need to look at what produces best healthcare for the community. We are modelling the impact of polyclinics and we need to wait for the outcome of this. The important principle is better patient care. |
||
| Will A&Es close as a result of polyclinics? | ||
| No. The polyclinic model will take pressure off A&E services. If we do nothing about changing the way we provide care we expect A&E attendances to increase by around 70% over the next 10 years. Current services simply will not be able to cope. | ||
Sovereign Court, 15 - 21 Staines Road, Hounslow, Middlesex, TW3 3HR
Tel: 020 8630 1000, Fax: 020 8630 3000
Email: communications.team@hounslowpct.nhs.uk. Copyright HPCT 2008

